அழிந்து கொண்டிருக்கும் திராவிடத்தை, தமிழ் தேசியம் பிடிக்கிறது! – டைம்ஸ் ஆப் இந்திய நாளிதழ் கட்டுரை!

the indus valley civilizations is believed to be a dravidian civilisations destroyed by aryans invaders: mohenjo daro site

the indus valley civilizations is believed to be a dravidian civilisations destroyed by aryans invaders: mohenjo daro site

அழிந்து கொண்டிருக்கும் திராவிடத்தை, தமிழ் தேசியம் பிடிக்கிறது! – டைம்ஸ் ஆப் இந்திய நாளிதழ் கட்டுரை!

Tamil Identity – `DRAVIDIAN IDENTITY, NOW A LOSING GAME’

In other parts of India, caste and religion are primary identities. But what is unique and complex to Tamil Nadu is its linguistic identity, which is undergoing a major transformation. It is unique because none of its neighbouring states has this problem. It is complex because the answer to the question who a Tamil is, is not simple. Tamil Nadu alone is grappling with a pseudo racial-linguistic identity called “Dravidian“.


ஒன்றுபட்ட உலகத் தமிழினத்தை உருவாக்க, இன்றே உலகத்மிழர் பேரவை – யுடன் இணைவீர்.  இணைய இங்கு அழுத்தவும்.


Dravidian refers to the language group comprising Tamil, Kannada, Telugu, Malayalam and Tulu which are all contiguous. It also includes Brahui which is spoken in the Baluch province of Pakistan.It was Francis Whyte Ellis, collector of Madras Province, who correctly identified that Tamil et al formed a linguistic group of their own that was apart from Sanskrit. He called it Dravidian. Robert Caldwell subsequently wrote a comparative grammar of these south Indian languages. Research by Burrow and Emeneau identified Dravidian root words distinct from the IndoAryan family of languages.

What was simply a linguistic exercise picked up momentum in the then Madras Province and took on a political colour. Findings of Madagascarian Lemur fossils in the Western Ghats resulted in the theory of Lemuria, a land mass where a pure Dravidian race supposedly originated, which was said to have been lost in the southern oceans.

When Sir John Marshall proposed the Aryan invasion theory after the Mohenjo Daro, Harappa excavations, the Dravidian theorists gleefully latched on to that and claimed Indus civilisation as a Dravidian civilisation which was destroyed by the invading Aryans. They said that the whole of India from Kumarikkandam (Lemuria) to Himalayas, including the Western Indus was populated by Dravidians.The marauding Aryans pushed them down south. The evidence? Brahui, a Dravidian language, spoken in Balu chistan.

This gave rise to Dravidian identity , of the great reign of the Tamil rulers, and the casteless and equitable societies mentioned in the Sangam poems following a religion that is not exactly compatible with the Vedic, Puranic Hindu religion. All ills of modern Tamil society could be blamed on the influence of Sanskrit, Vedas, Aryans and, primarily, brahmins. The Aryans not only drove the Dravidians down south, but also imposed their brahminical Hindu religion and caste system on the Dravidians. The Dravidians had to cast away the evils of the Aryan, brahminical Hindu influence and return to the glorious Sangam Dravidian era. Thus was born the opposites: Dravidian x Aryan, Tamil x Sanskrit, Casteless society x Caste-ridden society , Tamil religion x Hinduism.

The Dravidian identity revelled in being anti-Hindu, antibrahminical (because brahmins exemplify Hinduism, caste system and Sanskrit) and anti-Hindi (because Hindi is the modern representative of Sanskrit). Periyar’s Dravidar Kazhagam and the DMK subscribed to these ideas completely . This identity and the politics built on it helped the DMK capture power in TN.

Dravidian identity politics successfully vanquished other identities in Tamil Nadu for nearly 50 years. Over the last few years, however, a strong contender in the form of Tamil nationalism has emerged because Tamil Nadu got into river water disputes with all the neighbouring states and the neighbours did not seem to care much for Dravidian niceties although Telugus, Kannadigas and Malayalis are putatively Dravidian.

The Tamil nationalists, however, consider Dravidians as their number one enemy .Ramadoss of PMK, Seeman of Nam Tamilar Katchi and other fringe groups have been pushing this Tamil identity in recent times.

There is some confusion on the identity of Tamil speaking brahmins. The Dravidians are fairly clear that brahmins are Aryans. But some Tamil nationalists think brahmins can be included into their fold.They do not speak Sanskrit in any case, except a few mantras.

Thus, we now have a caste identity , a religious identity ,a narrow linguistic Tamil identity, and a complex racial-linguistic Dravidian identity . In this milieu, the BJP is trying to introduce the HinduIndian identity . The struggle in the coming years in capturing the identity market share may well see Dravidian identity shrinking and yielding space to Tamil identity and the HinduIndian identity.

Many youngsters who took part in the jallikkattu agitation will go through the question of their identity . Neither myth, nor real politics is in favour of Dravidian identity.

  • Badri Seshadri, Times Of  India

Related Post / தொடர்பு கட்டுரைகள் :

“தமிழ் நாயே, நான் உன்னை கொல்லுவேன்”, ப... "தமிழ் நாயே, நான் உன்னை கொல்லுவேன்", புத்த பிக்கு, சிங்கள காவல்துறையின் முன்னேயே, தமிழ் கிராம நல அலுவலரை பார்த்து மட்டக்களப்பில் குரைப்பு! "தமிழ் நா...
‘தமிழும், தமிழரும் செழிக்க உலகத் தமிழர்கள் ஒ... 'தமிழும், தமிழரும் செழிக்க உலகத் தமிழர்கள் ஒன்றிணைய வேண்டும்' - உலகத் தமிழர்கள் ஒன்றுபட சென்னையில் நடைபெற்ற தமிழ் உலக சந்திப்பு! சென்ற சனிக்கிழமை (0...
உலகத் தமிழர் பேரவை இன்று, தமிழ் இனத்திற்காகவும், ம... உலகத் தமிழர் பேரவை இன்று, தமிழ் இனத்திற்காகவும், மொழிக்காகவும் இன்னுயிரை ஈகை செய்த மாவீரர்களுக்கு வீர வணக்கம் செலுத்தப்பட்டது! உலக முழுக்க உள்ள தமிழ...
“சிந்துவெளியில் இன்றும் தமிழ் ஊர்ப்பெயர்கள்”... சிந்துவெளியில் இன்றும் தமிழ் ஊர்ப்பெயர்கள் 1980களில், ஒரிசாவில் நான் பார்த்த ஒரு ஊரின் பெயர்ப் பலகை என்னை தடுத்து நிறுத்தியது. அந்த பெயர் ‘தமிழி’. க...
Tags: 
%d bloggers like this: